by
Erwin B. Montgomary, Jr., M.D. Associate Professor of
Neurology University of Arizona College of Medicine Medical
DirectorAPDA Information & Referral Center Tucson, Arizona Source:
APDA Newsletter Fall 1996
Wouldn't it be wonderful to be
able to slow the progression of Parkinson's disease
(PD) or even prevent it?
Researchers worldwide are developing new treatments
that may make this dream a reality.
In
order for these treatments to fulfill their promise,
however, physicians will need a way to diagnose PD "pre-clinically,"
that is, before symptoms such as tremor, stiffness and
slowness become evident. The characteristic signs and
symptoms of Parkinson's disease do not appear until
approximately 80% of the dopamine-producing neurons
in the brain have died off, a process which takes many
years. If treatments to slow the progression of the
illness could be initiated before 80% of these neurons
were lost, it might be possible to delay or even prevent
disability. Unfortunately, most Parkinson patients are
not diagnosed until the symptoms are well established.
Diagnosing PD early, when the signs and symptoms are
subtle, can be very difficult, even for experts. Unlike
many other illnesses which may be confirmed with laboratory
tests, there is no widely-accepted test to help the
physician confirm PD as the cause of the patient's symptoms.
Epidemiological studies suggest that up to 40% of individuals
with the disease are unidentified and untreated. In
a survey of 93 Parkinson patients in Southern Arizona,
22% reported it took more than a year from the time
they first complained of symptoms to a physician to
the time they received a diagnosis, and not infrequently,
the initial diagnosis was incorrect.
Approximately
8% reported waiting two years for an accurate diagnosis.
When you add this one to two year period to the year
or so most patients spend wondering what's wrong before
seeking a doctor's opinion, it becomes clear that getting
a diagnosis takes far too long, particularly if the
goal is early treatment designed to keep disability
at bay. Currently under study at the University of Arizona
are three tests which, when used together, may provide
the first reliable way to diagnose PD early and to distinguish
it from similar disorders and from normal aging. The
test battery includes a test of olfaction (sense of
smell), a test of mood, and a test for speed and accuracy
of movement. Loss of sense of smell and abnormalities
of mood such as depression are commonly observed in
Parkinson patients. In many cases, these conditions
predate the diagnosis by several years. The movement
test uses a video game to assess the speed and accuracy
of a specific type of wrist movement. Earlier studies
were conducted with non-human primates who were trained
to perform a wrist task and then tested before and after
being made Parkinsonian with the neurotoxin MPTP. Recording
of neuronal activity in these animals while they were
performing the wrist movements showed that many nerve
cells in the brain are important in achieving the specific
type of movement required in the wrist task. This finding
pointed the way to the development of special tests
of motor function that are highly sensitive to Parkinson's
disease. The diagnostic value of the three tests used
together is much better than that of one of the tests
used alone. We have tested more than 50 normal older
individuals and 50 Parkinson patients who were either
newly diagnosed or very early in their disease. Our
test battery was over 90% specific and 90% sensitive
in differentiating the Parkinson patient with mild symptoms
from the normal older individual. It has proven especially
useful for distinguishing between Parkinson patients
and patients with essential tremor, a distinction many
experienced clinicians find diffficult to make.
Just
how early can we identify a person who might be at risk
for Parkinson's disease? This is the next step in our
research. We hope to study a large number of older individuals
whose symptoms suggest PD but are not sufficient to
make a firm diagnosis. We will test these individuals
with the three-part battery and follow them for two
years. Then we will be able to determine just how accurately
the battery detects the disease in its early, most subtle
form. Another potential use for the test battery is
to help us understand the genetic basis for Parkinson's
disease. Current research suggests there may be a gene
that plays a role in the development of PD but that
not everyone who inherits this gene will actually develop
the illness. Most likely, heredity is only part of the
picture and environmental factors are also important.
Because the disease is usually diagnosed in mid-life
or later, it is usually the case that the son or daughter
of a Parkinsonian, if he or she is to develop the illness,
will do so only after the affected parent has died.
This situation makes it difficult to do the studies
that would establish the genetic link. Testing the adult
children of Parkinsons with the three-part battery increases
the likelihood that families with both an affected parent
and an affected son or daughter can be identified while
both parties are still alive and able to participate
in genetic research. When a genetic test becomes available,
the three-part battery will assist first degree relatives
of Parkinsonians in getting the earliest diagnosis possible.
If they are developing PD. With advances in treatments
to slow the progression of PD, all patients will benefit
from early detection. Actress Lynn Redgrave participated
in Dr. Erwin Montomery's research study on pre-clinical
detection of PD. Her father, Sir Michael Redgrave had
Parkinson's disease and died in 1986. Lynn was in Tucson
performing her one-woman show Shakespeare For My Father,
a play which addresses the subject of Parkinson's head-on.
The play presents a poignant picture of how the illness
affected her father and her family.
In a television interview at the APDA reception which
followed her final performance in Tucson, Lynn said,
"Because my father was a man of extraordinar,v facial
mobility who was able to play characters with such extraordinary
emotion across his face, it was a particularly cruel
blow, that he should be stricken with a disease that
robs the face of expression. I think that was the hardest
thing for us as a family." Of her experience being tested
by Dr. Montgomery she had this to say: "It was a really
simple process that took less than an hour, and it gave
me a certain peace of mind. While Dr. Montgomary explained
that there is no definite way to say "Lynn you will
never get Parkinson's disease", at least there was no
sign of it during my test. The test was extremely simple
and didn't involve anything painful or hard. In fact,
it was really quite fun, I think his work is very exciting
and I can't wait to tell my brother and sister."
|